Solving Crime Requires Transparent Crime Data

By Joel P. Engardio

Much of the publicly available crime data in San Francisco doesn’t tell the full story, especially when it comes to domestic violence crimes.

There were 131 felony domestic violence cases in the final quarter last year — and 113 were dismissed. Of the 19 cases involving children, 13 were dismissed.

That’s why Supervisor Catherine Stefani passed legislation that will force the district attorney’s office and the police department to provide the public with quarterly reports on how often domestic violence offenders are arrested and prosecuted.

Here’s why the legislation was needed: Our district attorney’s office has a data dashboard called “ DA Stat.” But it doesn’t mention what happens to cases beyond the initial filing of charges. The public deserves to see sentencing information and final disposition — because it’s the outcome of a case that matters.

An open, disciplined tracking of cases from start to end should be a requirement for every district attorney’s office. Without it, people on both sides of the crime debate have to rely on emotional anecdotes instead of data on actual outcomes.

Transparent crime data that is easily accessible to the public is essential for improving public safety.

We need to know:

  • How many crimes are actually committed and how criminals are being held accountable.
  • How many people released before trial commit a new crime.
  • How often diversion programs rehabilitate people as a preferable alternative to jail time.
  • How often jail is warranted for a repeat offender who has already been offered parole and a diversion program.

Lessons From Chicago
Maybe we can learn from Chicago, where Kim Foxx is a progressive district attorney. She determines which crimes get prosecuted — and she knows that transparency is what will build credibility and support for her justice reform policies. That’s why Foxx provides her constituents an online data dashboard. It lets residents see what’s happening with thousands of cases, from initial charge through final sentencing.

Why don’t we have anything as comprehensive as this in San Francisco? Our district attorney’s office has a dashboard called “ DA Stat “ that can’t compare to what Chicago has.

San Francisco lacks accessible data because City Hall fumbled the creation of the Justice Tracking Information System. After two decades in the making, it still doesn’t fully function. We sit at the center of Silicon Valley and tech advancement, yet City Hall’s attempt at public safety data sharing has been a debacle.

Good Data Matters
Safety and justice should go together. Justice reform is necessary. And for it to work, residents must feel confident public officials are doing their job to keep everyone safe. This requires transparent and accessible crime data residents can trust.

Good data would help residents understand what is really happening in our district attorney’s office, the police department, and the courts. That’s why we must ask officials to put all crime data in the the open.

Originally published at on November 14, 2021.




Forward-thinking + pragmatic Democrat, civil liberties advocate, award-winning journalist, Westside SF homeowner. My local views at

Love podcasts or audiobooks? Learn on the go with our new app.

Recommended from Medium

The Heather Cook Case: A Notorious Hit-and-Run DUI Fatality

A grinning man with white hair and glasses stands on the left, with his left arm around the shoulder of a smiling young girl. To the right is part of a bike frame.

The Roe-to-Prison Pipeline

a corridor inside a jail showing cells with bars on both sides of the corridor

Outrageous Human-Meat Lover Didn’t Hide His Strange Tendencies

ACAB. But read this first.

One Possible Upstream A2J Solution: A look at court funding

CDCR’s COVID-19 Population Reduction Actions


When She Fell In Love With Her Adoptive Family's Son, Things Went South

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Joel Engardio

Joel Engardio

Forward-thinking + pragmatic Democrat, civil liberties advocate, award-winning journalist, Westside SF homeowner. My local views at

More from Medium

Historical Bike Adventure To Discover Real Story of Chippewa Flowage

Despite knowing a little about American Indian history in Wisconsin, I never knew that the Chippewa Flowage was created when a power company, without approval from the Ojibwe tribe, built a dam on the Chippewa River and flooded thousands of acres of tribal land.

Only A Sith Deals In Absolutes

Auto Attendant Hell

The Kashmir Files